Don's Home
![]() | |
Under Construction ![]() |
Maping Software (2008 review) Creek Mtns Lake Exit Multiple Names Name nums Sizes Counties Size MapQuest 1 y n * y y y 690x526 * requires zoom 2 for lake names Yahoo n n y y n y 620x500 Google n n y n ? n 705x725 MapsOnUs n n n y y n 338x338 good for secondary road, had new street when above did not. Map @ MSN n y n MS TerraServer n y Aerial Photos & Topo maps - Labels Natl Forest khtml World Map 1. Mapquest found towns (e.g. Concord in Lancaster Co., PA) which others did not. See Examples Directions - Travel Times When getting directions from JFK airport to my son's wedding near Rhinebeck, NY Google, Mapquest and Yahoo all gave different routes with different times. When I changed the google route to match mapquest the time was close to the shortest google time, but still shorter than the mapquest time. According to some of the older reviews I found on the web Google used to give longer times. I know I used to be able to beat the google time easily, however recently (2012) google times are shorter. The question is are they just using the speed limit or averaging for slow traffic or allowing time for coffee breaks on long trips. See tests below. A 2008 blog Why use MapQuest for long trips? | Human-Computer Interaction @ IU says, people use MapQuest of long trips because it gives better local information for areas people are not familiar with. But, MapQuest has changed in the last 4 years. A 2010 article in PCWorld gave Google and 8/10, Bing a 7/10 and MapQuest 6/10 Google Maps Vs MapQuest One-on-One Comparison at driving-directions.org A 2008 forum comment at askville.amazon.com says, For the last year, I had been traveling a lot and for every trip, I made sure to compare the directions of Google maps and mapquest. More than 95% of the time, I ended up choosing mapquest because it not only gave me the shortest route but also gave me the fastest route besides giving me good time estimates. My tests Dec., 2012I-80 where there is little traffic from NJ to Western PA from 41 Vreeland Ave, Totowa, NJ to 862 Perry Hwy, Mercer, PA Google 356 mi 5:24 = 66 MPH MapQuest 350.9 mi 5:42 = 62 MPH Bing 350.9 mi 5:00 = 70 MPH If you drive 73 MPH you get 4:53 driving time. With two gas/coffee/bathroom stops of 15 min. each you get 5:23 which is the same as google's time. Washington D.C. I-495 Capital Beltway - Speed Limit 55 MPH 4095 Powder Mill Road, Beltsville, MD to 7200 Old Keen Mill Rd., Springfield, VA South North Google 33.8 mi 38 min = 54 MPH 43 min. 47 MPH MapQuest 33.5 mi 42 min = 48 MPH 45 Min 45 MPH You get the same results for average time with different time of day and days of the week. Google maps now show time in current traffic under the average time. Examples South North 10 AM Fri. 38 min 2:30 PM Fri 38 min 46 min 4:00 PM Fri 38 min 52 min 6:20 PM Fri 41 min 50 min 11:15 PM Fri 38 min 43 min (It looks like they never post a current traffic time faster than the average) Google will show you traffic at a given day or time. Click the traffic dropdown in the upper right. Click traffic again. Example for New York City Click change in the Live Traffic legend at the lower left to change the day and time. At Are the travel times on Google maps calculated by according to the speed limits? - Yahoo! Answers in 2010 they said, "Distance and average speed, they can't take into account time spent at traffic lights, fuel stops, traffic accidents (if any). See How Google Traffic Works: Where Traffic Data Comes From & How Google Maps are Updated with Traffic Views iPhone 6 In 2012 Apple dropped google as the source for their maps app creating a lot of criticism. They have been working to fix it. Tests by Ars Technica in Oct. 2012, recommended the google maps in a web browser.Find the latitude and longitude of street addresses in the US at GPSVisualizer.com, BatchGeoCode.com | |
DirectionsUS MapsHiking topo maps
|
World MapsCity LookupMapsPlanet Country MapsExamples:
Lonely Planet
Map CD's and Printed maps |
See also: Return to Reference or Travel |