Contents: Home Electronic and tools | Lead Acid | links: lead-acid | links: other
Home Electronic and tools
Home Ni-Cd NiCAD (Nickel Cadmium) - has memory effect
NiMH (Nickel Metal Hydride) - higher capacity and are mostly memory free
Li-Ion (Lithium Ion) - highest capacity and the lightest weight, memory-free.
Li-Poly (Lithium Polymer). ultra-lightweight & does not explode. memory-free.
Sealed Lead Acid (SLA) - Heavy, Shorter life, must be kept at full
charge during storage.
Alkalines - Disposable, inexpensive.
Nickel oxy-hydroxide similar to alkalines. Better performance in a digital camera,
worse in a CD player.
Both NiCd and SLA batteries can be severely damaged by being
deeply discharged to down below 75% of their rated voltage
In Battery Life at climber.org Richard Booth wrote:
- For gear with a high power drain (Video camera) or for devices you use often, rechargeable (NiMH) batteries are much more economical than disposables.
- NiMH cells discharge when they're not in use, so they're not the best choice for battery-powered devices that often sit idle.
- For a digital camera, buy disposable lithium. They retain most of their power for years when in storage.
- low- or medium-draw gear e.g. a CD player, buy a highly rated alkaline.
I have shifted to NiMH for most applications in order to cut down on the disposing of batteries. They work well in cameras, headlamps, gps, etc. Just a personal preference.
See: Battery Guide -- Battery types, pros & cons, comparisons, tips & tricks by Michael Bluejay for a good table like the following.
- Primary cell (not rechargeable). These have good shelf life, that is they can be left around for years and still maintain good capacity. Poor high current drain applications such as digital cameras but ok for headlamps. Poor low temperature performance. Checking the capacity specifications should reveal the rate, in a fraction of the capacity, that they can be discharged. Usually .1C or for a 2500 mahour battery this would be 250 ma for about ten hours at room temperature. Typical capacities are 2500 mahour.
- Nickle metal hydride. Secondary cell (re-chargeable). These have poor shelf life and will supposedly discharge in some months. I use these in a digtal camera and they work well for months in this application going through hundreds of pictures. A set of alakalines will barely make it to about 40 pictures. NiMH are initially expensive but if re-charged about ten times the cost is approximately the same as alkaline. The weight of the NiMH batteries is about the same as alakaline. Typical high performance cells run about 1700 mahour which is less than alkaline. My NiMH batteries in my digital camera worked ok at -17F winter ice climbing. NiMH is supposedly better than alkaline at cold temperatures but the curves only modestly support this. One observation: get NiMH from a reputable source. They are sold by all sorts of bogus types. Try Thomas Distributing for Maha batteries and charger.
- The variations of lithium batteries is huge and the teminal voltages come in a wide selection. The equivalent to the 1.5 V alakaline seems to be made only by Eveready. These are primary cells and cannot be re-charged. The cost is large, about $2.50 per battery, but they weigh about 60% of an alkaline and have about 3x the capacity. They work well in cameras. They are supposedly the low temperature kings. They have tremendous shelf life. I used a pair of surplus lithium batteries, bought for $.50, to run a piece of ham gear. They were at least ten years old and provided about 90% of the capacity after years of being stored in a hot garage.
Source: What is the perfect battery? by Isidor Buchmann, President Cadex Electronics
Energy Density (Wh/kg)
|| 80 (initial)
(includes peripheral circuits) in mW
| 100 to 2001
| 200 to 3001
| 150 to 2501
| 200 to 3001
| 200 to 20001
Life (to 80% of initial capacity)
|| 300 to 5002,3
|| 200 to
| 500 to 10003
|| 300 to
|| 1h typical
|| very low
/ Month (room temperature)
- best result
0.5C or lower
1C or lower
1C or lower
0.2C or lower
Temperature (discharge only)
|| -40 to
| -20 to
| -20 to
| -20 to
| 0 to
| 0 to
|| 30 to 60 days
|| 60 to 90 days
|| 3 to 6 months9
|| not req.
|| not req.
|| not req.
(US$, reference only)
per Cycle (US$)11
In addition to their typical use as starter motors in vehicles and boats, lead acid batteries are used for:
- Internal resistance of a battery pack varies with cell rating, type of protection circuit and number of cells. Protection circuit of Li-ion and Li-polymer adds about 100mW.
- Cycle life is based on battery receiving regular maintenance. Failing to apply periodic full discharge cycles may reduce the cycle life by a factor of three.
- Cycle life is based on the depth of discharge. Shallow discharges provide more cycles than deep discharges.
- The discharge is highest immediately after charge, then tapers off. The NiCd capacity decreases 10% in the first 24h, then declines to about 10% every 30 days thereafter. Self-discharge increases with higher temperature.
- Internal protection circuits typically consume 3% of the stored energy per month.
- 1.25V is the open cell voltage. 1.2V is the commonly used value. There is no difference between the cells; it is simply a method of rating.
- Capable of high current pulses.
- Applies to discharge only; charge temperature range is more confined.
- Maintenance may be in the form of 'equalizing' or 'topping' charge.
- Cost of battery for commercially available portable devices.
- Derived from the battery price divided by cycle life. Does not include the cost of electricity and chargers.
- Power for lights and accessories on Recreational Vehicles (RVs, campers, boats, ...)
- Solar electric (PV) power storage, backup power
- Emergency power for amateur radio (ham) systems.
- Motor drives in star tracking systems on telescopes.
- Radio Control (RC) model hobbists
- Golf Carts, Wheel chairs, trolling motors
- Winches for off-road vehicles (see jeep config)
There are specalized types of Lead Acid batteries for these purposes.
See the Battery page in the Auto section for more information on Lead-Acid batteries for cars and trucks.
See Charactistics below.
- Flooded/wet cell Lead Acid - Typical car battery with 6 2V cells and caps on top for adding water. Called flooded because the lead plates are flooded with liquid Sulfuric acid (H2SO4).
- Sealed Lead acid (SLA) or Gas-recombinant VRLA (Valve Regulated Lead-Acid) batteries here are "sort of" sealed. They still
should be kept top side up. There is still a vent for Hydrogen
gas to escape, but a twisted vent that usually stops any acid leaks.
Their greatest disadvantage is the high initial cost (two to three times over wet low maintenance) but arguably can have an overall lower total cost of ownership due to a longer lifetime and no "watering" labor costs.
- AGM: Absorbed Glass Mat batteries.
AGM batteries are also sometimes called "starved electrolyte" or "dry", because the fiberglass mat is only 95% saturated with Sulfuric acid and there is no excess liquid.
The plates in an AGM battery may be flat like wetcell lead-acid battery, or they may be wound in a tight spiral.
They are being used in race cars and motorcycles because of vibraation resistance and educed likelihood of acid-spilling during accidents.
- A gel-cell is a type of lead acid battery in a sealed
case with a gelled electrolyte. They are "valve regulated", which means that a tiny valve keeps a slight positive pressure. Gel cells are more suitable in
applications where the battery may be in different positions (as they
can't spill electrolyte) and where they are not regularly inspected for
leaks and electrolyte levels.
- Carbon Foam Lead Acid batteries:
A new taechnology which replaces the heavy lead grids with a graphite foam. Reticulated vitreous carbon ("RVC") plates are created and a lead tin alloy is deposited on the RVC plate by electroplating. Battery paste is applied onto the individual RVC plates, and they are cured.
Most smaller deep cycle batteries (including AGM) use Lead-Calcium plates for increased life, while most industrial and forklift batteries use Lead-Antimony for greater plate strength.
Gel Cells - 3-225Ah - $2 - $7.50/Ah
Jump Start batteries (Gel cells with jumper cables, lights, - 8-18Ah - $40-$80
You can get high powered ones with 2, 22-Ah Professional-Grade, High-Output AGM Batteries for $500.
Deep Cycle wet cells - 50 - 225 Ah - $1 - $2.50 / Ah
Deep Cycle Industrial wet cells 300-1800 Ah - $2 - 3.30 / Ah
Lead-acid battery prices have been fluctuating frequently due to the changing cost of lead.
Effect of Temperature:
- Lead Acid:
Typical 12-volt lead-acid batteries have a voltage of about 14 volts when fully charged and 11 volts fully discharged.
A name brand car/marine battery and charger which will turn off automatically ($60 + $50) will work much better than cheap battery and charger ($35 + $20).
Buy a "deep discharge" or "deep cycle" if you buy lead acid. These are
used on sail boats, on lakes for fishing, etc.
Engine starting batteries perform poorly for communications because they are designed for short periods of high load. Deep cycle batteries are better for communications because they withstand long periods of slow discharge.
Deep cycle or Deep discharge batteries are designed to be discharged down as much as 80% time after time, and have much thicker plates. The major difference between a true deep cycle battery and others is that the plates are SOLID Lead plates - not sponge. This gives less surface area, thus less "instant" power like starting batteries need.
Amp-hour ratings of deep cycle batteries are based upon a discharge rate at 1/20 capacity, expressed as C over 20". A marine battery rated 200ah at C20, when discharged continuously at 10 amps, at 80° F., sustains the load for 20 hrs.
Most smaller deep cycle batteries (including AGM) use Lead-Calcium plates for increased life.
Deep cycle batteries can't accept very high charging rates. If you charge from a car with a really hot alternator that can flow a lot of amps, you need to make sure your deep cycle battery can accept the charge rate.
See Deep Cycle in Products
Total charge time and current should not exceed 140% of battery capacity.
A simple test load for small gel cells up to 20ah is a 50w, 12V marine/RV bulb or automotive drop light, which draws about 3.8A, equal to a mobile radio on low power a 5w transmit or a portable 2-meter hand held, plus a laptop computer. Two bulbs on a Y adapter simulate a mobile radio at 25w RF output and are a good test load for batteries to 30amp-hours. In a good battery voltage drop stabilizes quickly, does not fall below 11.5V under load and recovers quickly when the test load is removed.
- Gel Cell:
Batteries using "recombination technology" (used in gel-cells) suffer from
multiple failure modes, ie. premature dryout, thermal runaway, sensitivity to
AC ripple to name a few. Their life is shorter than a flooded
Gel cell longevity has a lot to do with the charging rate. One must charge
these batteries very slowly with a 500mA trickle charger.
Gel cells should never be charged at over 14V.
The standard rating for batteries is at room temperature - 25 degrees C (about 77 F). At approximately -22 degrees F (-27 C), battery AH capacity drops to 50%. At freezing, capacity is reduced by 20%.
Links: (Lead Acid)
Car Batteries in Auto
Terms/Glossary in Auto.
Deep Cycle in Products
Charging Electronics and 12 volt batteries in Tech
Gel-cell VS Sealed Lead Acid Battery for Astronomy at sci.astro.amateur group
Battery Guide at DiffLock 4x4
Camping Power Management Tips by George Schreyer;
Deep Cycle Battery FAQ, an extraordinarily useful, informative, and comprehensive webpage, by Northern Arizona Wind & Sun, Inc., with a list of helpful links at the end;
CAR AND DEEP CYCLE BATTERY FAQ, compiled by Bill Darden: a plethora of links to informative articles;
Deep Cycle Battery FAQ at N. Arizona Wind&Sun
Vector Jumpstart & Power Supply 17 AH
Car Batteries in Auto
Battery Guide -- Battery types, pros & cons, comparisons, tips & tricks by Michael Bluejay
Terms in the auto battery page
Battery sources at products
New Technology Batteries Guide: Fundamentals of Battery Technology
What is the perfect battery? by Isidor Buchmann, President Cadex Electronics
Computer Battery Help at ComputerHope.com
Battery Related Questions at AtBatt.com
How Batteries Work at HowStuffWorks.com
Charging in Technology here
Best Batteries and Match the batteries to your gear at ConsumerReports.org
Battery Power Basics at The Connection fron North American Emergency Communications (NAEM)
Best alkaline batteries?
AtBatt.com FAQs - Battery Related Questions
Return to Products
last updated 22 Apr 2008